“Put your hands down,” the officer barked behind me, loud enough to make the marble hallway echo. I’d come to the Franklin County Courthouse early, hair pulled back, a plain navy suit, no robe—just another woman walking past security with a leather tote and a stack of case notes. I wasn’t trying to be invisible. I just didn’t expect to be seen as a threat.
“I’m heading to Courtroom 4B,” I said, keeping my voice even.
He stepped closer. “Don’t get smart with me. Hands where I can see them.”
People turned. A clerk froze with a file folder mid-air. A public defender whispered, “Oh no,” like he’d watched this movie before.
“My hands are down,” I said. “I’m not resisting anything.”
The officer—later I’d learn his name was Deputy Mark Caldwell—grabbed my wrist anyway, jerking my arm up as if I’d stolen something. My tote slid off my shoulder and hit the floor. Papers fanned out—sentencing memos, a printed calendar, and a folder stamped JUDICIAL ASSIGNMENT. He didn’t look at any of it.
“Stop pulling away,” he snapped.
“I’m not pulling—” I started.
That’s when his palm cracked across my cheek.
It wasn’t dramatic like TV. It was quick, efficient, practiced. The shock landed first, then heat, then the metallic taste of blood where my teeth caught my lip. For a second, the hallway went silent except for the squeak of someone’s shoes and the far-off buzz of a fluorescent light.
Someone muttered, “He just slapped her.”
Another voice—soft, ugly—added, “She’s just… a Black woman.”
I stared at him, steady. My face throbbed, but my voice didn’t. “You’re in the wrong courtroom,” I said, quiet enough to make him lean in, close enough to smell his coffee.
Caldwell scoffed. “You threatening me?”
“No,” I answered. “I’m warning you.”
A bailiff hurried over, eyes wide. “Ma’am—are you okay?”
I bent, gathered my papers, and slid the stamped folder back into my tote. Then I walked past Caldwell without touching him, without raising my voice, without giving him the satisfaction of fear.
Inside Courtroom 4B, the clerk looked up at me like she’d seen a ghost. She swallowed hard. “Judge Thompson…?”
I nodded once.
The courtroom stood. The robe waited behind the bench. I stepped up, put it on, and took my seat. The gavel felt heavier than usual in my hand.
Deputy Caldwell appeared at the doorway, still wearing that smug certainty—until he saw me on the bench.
I leaned forward, eyes locked on his. “Deputy Caldwell,” I said into the mic, calm as a verdict. “Step forward. Now.”
You could hear a pin drop as Caldwell walked toward the rail. His face shifted through disbelief, embarrassment, and something that looked like anger trying to hide behind professionalism. He straightened his shoulders as if posture could erase what he’d done.
“Yes, Your Honor?” he said, voice tighter than before.
I didn’t touch my cheek. I didn’t dab the blood. I let the courtroom see exactly what authority had done in a public hallway. “Before we begin today’s docket,” I said, “I need to address an incident that occurred outside this courtroom.”
The prosecutor glanced down at her notes like she wished ink could swallow her. The defense attorney stared at Caldwell with a look that said, Finally. The court reporter’s fingers hovered over the keys.
Caldwell tried first with denial. “Your Honor, I was maintaining security. She—this individual—was noncompliant.”
I raised my tote slightly. “This ‘individual’ is me. Judge Maya Thompson. And I was walking to my assigned courtroom with documents clearly identifying me.” I set the stamped folder on the bench where everyone could see it. “Explain why you escalated a routine hallway encounter to physical violence.”
He swallowed. “I didn’t know who you were.”
“That’s your defense?” I asked. “That you would only refrain from striking a woman if you recognized her title?”
A ripple moved through the gallery—quiet, but real. Caldwell’s jaw clenched. He tried a different angle. “She—You—moved suddenly.”
“I bent to pick up my tote after you yanked my arm,” I said. “That isn’t sudden. That’s human.”
I could feel the bruise forming, a steady pulse beneath my skin. But the pain wasn’t the worst part. The worst part was how normal it had felt—for everyone watching. Like they were waiting to see whether I’d earn the right to be treated with basic dignity.
I signaled to the bailiff. “Call Chief Deputy Ronald Pierce to the courtroom.”
Minutes later, Pierce arrived, out of breath, carrying the forced smile of a man already calculating damage control. “Judge Thompson,” he said quickly, eyes flicking to my face. “I—uh—heard there was a misunderstanding.”
“A misunderstanding is a mixed-up date on a hearing notice,” I replied. “Assault is something else.”
Pierce’s smile died. “We can handle this internally.”
“We will handle this properly,” I said. “On the record.”
Caldwell’s eyes flashed. “Your Honor, are you accusing me—”
“I’m stating what happened,” I cut in. “And I’m ordering the preservation of all hallway security footage from 8:10 to 8:25 a.m. today. No gaps. No ‘technical difficulties.’ If that footage is altered or disappears, I will refer the matter for criminal investigation.”
That got him. He shifted, suddenly aware that the room wasn’t his. “Yes, Your Honor,” he muttered.
Then I did something I knew would be unpopular with the people who preferred quiet compromises: I recessed the court.
Gasps, protests, whispers. Docket schedules were sacred in this building—more sacred than bruised faces, apparently. But I wasn’t going to preside over anyone else’s liberty while my own body was treated like courthouse furniture.
In chambers, Pierce tried bargaining. “Judge, think about the backlash. The headlines. The union.”
I looked him straight in the eye. “I am the headline,” I said. “And I’m done paying for other people’s comfort.”
He lowered his voice. “What do you want?”
I thought of every woman who’d been told she was “overreacting,” every Black person who’d been treated as suspicious by default, every clerk in that hallway who’d looked away because looking was risky.
“I want accountability,” I said. “And I want it in daylight.”
Pierce exhaled, defeated. “Then you’ll get a formal complaint. An investigation.”
“Good,” I said. “Because that slap didn’t start with me. It just ended with the wrong person.”
By afternoon, the security footage was sitting in an evidence envelope on my desk, signed and dated. It showed exactly what my body already knew: I stood still, spoke calmly, and complied with instructions that made no sense. Caldwell grabbed my wrist first. My tote hit the floor. I bent to retrieve it. His hand came up, fast and clean, and my head snapped slightly to the side.
There was no “sudden movement.” No threat. No justification.
The next morning, I came back to the courthouse with a faint purple bloom on my cheekbone and a stronger one in my chest—the kind that forms when your anger finally finds a spine. I held a brief hearing on the record with Chief Deputy Pierce, a representative from the county counsel’s office, and Caldwell’s union rep. Nobody could claim confusion. Nobody could pretend it was hearsay.
Caldwell’s union rep tried the familiar script. “Deputy Caldwell has served this county for twelve years. He has a family. He made a split-second decision under stress.”
I kept my hands folded. “A split-second decision is still a decision,” I said. “And stress doesn’t create bias—it reveals it.”
Caldwell finally spoke, and for a second his voice sounded smaller than his badge. “I didn’t mean—” he began, then stopped, like the rest of the sentence would incriminate him.
I waited. Silence is a tool on the bench, and I’ve learned to use it. When he didn’t continue, I said, “What you meant doesn’t change what you did.”
The county counsel reviewed the footage twice. Pierce looked like he’d aged a year in one night. In the end, they couldn’t do what institutions love most—bury it.
Caldwell was placed on immediate leave pending investigation. The Sheriff’s Office agreed, in writing, to updated courthouse training, clearer identification protocols for visiting judges, and—most important to me—a policy requiring an automatic outside review for any use of force inside the courthouse. Not a favor. Not a “we’ll see.” A requirement.
That didn’t heal my cheek. It didn’t rewind the hallway whispers. But it did something else: it forced the building to admit what it had been trained to ignore.
Later, as I walked out past the same metal detector, a young Black woman in a public defender badge stopped me. Her name tag read TAYLOR REED. Her voice shook, but her eyes didn’t. “Judge Thompson,” she said, “thank you for not letting them make it disappear.”
I swallowed, surprised by the sting behind my eyes. “I almost did,” I admitted. “For about ten seconds. Then I remembered how many people don’t get to choose.”
She nodded once, like she understood exactly what I meant, and stepped aside to let me pass.
Outside, the winter air bit my skin. I touched the edge of the bruise—not to hide it, but to remind myself it was real. Real things can be proven. Real things can be challenged. Real things can change policy.
And here’s what I want to ask you—because this doesn’t end with my courtroom: If you saw this happen in a courthouse hallway, would you speak up, film it, or report it… or would you look away and tell yourself it’s “not your problem”?
If this story hit you, drop a comment with what you would’ve done in that moment—and if you’ve ever witnessed something like this, share how it was handled. Your voice might be the reason the next incident doesn’t get erased.




